What's in this book
- Joe Abercrombie's 2007 second First Law novel - the war moves to the South and the Northmen prepare for the Northern campaign
- Second volume of the First Law trilogy; canonical contemporary grimdark fantasy
- 551 pages expanding the political-fantasy worldbuilding the first volume established
- Series continues across Last Argument of Kings (2008) and the Age of Madness trilogy
- Steven Pacey audiobook is the definitive audio production
- For readers of A Clash of Kings, The Way of Kings, and the broader contemporary grimdark fantasy tradition
Buy this book
Books N Bytes participates in affiliate programs including Amazon Associates and Bookshop.org. We may earn a commission when you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you.
The middle book of a fantasy trilogy is the hardest one to write. Most writers solve the problem by raising the stakes mechanically. Joe Abercrombie solves it by sending three of his characters on impossible missions in three different directions and letting each thread accumulate moral cost. By the end of Before They Are Hanged, every protagonist is worse than they started, and the books somehow make this feel like progress.
Logen and Bayaz go on a long, miserable quest into a ruined east that drips menace from every chapter. Glokta is sent to defend an indefensible city and inquisitions ensue. Jezal goes to war and discovers, slowly, that he is not the person he assumed he was. All three threads work. The Glokta defense of Dagoska is some of the best siege writing in modern fantasy.
Abercrombie's dialogue is the engine, again. There is a sequence between Glokta and the city governor that I went back and reread the moment I finished it. Five stars. Read The Blade Itself first, then this, then Last Argument of Kings and accept that the next month is gone.
Related reads
If you liked Before They Are Hanged
The Blade Itself
by Joe Abercrombie
Grimdark fantasy with a beating heart underneath the cynicism. Abercrombie writes the kind of characters you would cross a kingdom for.
Last Argument Of Kings
by Joe Abercrombie
The final First Law book. Abercrombie sticks every landing he had been setting up for two books, and the result is bleak in the best way.
A Clash of Kings
by George R. R. Martin
A Clash of Kings by George R. R. Martin 1998 review. Five claimants vie for the Iron Throne while a comet crosses the sky over Westeros. The middle volume of A Song of Ice and Fire and the one most committed Martin readers consider his peak.
A Game of Thrones
by George R. R. Martin
A Game of Thrones by George R. R. Martin 1996 review. The book that rewrote what epic fantasy was allowed to do. Westeros, the Iron Throne, the deaths nobody saw coming. Required reading.
American Gods
by Neil Gaiman
American Gods by Neil Gaiman 2001 review. An ex-convict named Shadow takes a job as bodyguard to a strange man named Wednesday and learns the old gods of immigration are still here, dying slow. The defining American urban fantasy of the 2000s.
Mistborn: The Final Empire
by Brandon Sanderson
Mistborn: The Final Empire by Brandon Sanderson 2006 review. A street urchin named Vin discovers she can use magic by ingesting and burning metals, and a crew of thieves recruits her for the impossible: kill the immortal Lord Ruler.
More by this author